What Can We Do For You Today?

We are here to help

Commercial and business insurance solutions icon - keatsagency.com

Business & Commercial

Homeowners and property insurance icon - keatsagency.com

Home

Personal and commercial auto insurance icon - keatsagency.com

Auto

Life insurance and financial protection icon - keatsagency.com

Life

Specialized Solutions for all Your Insurance Needs


Why Do Business With Us


There’s good reason to do business with Keats Insurance Agencies. We choose kindness first; offer genuine care; deliver proficient and appropriate advice.

We take the time to listen which some may say is a lost art.

Insurance should match your needs, and that starts with listening. Keats Insurance Agencies ensures your coverage fits you.
Insurance isn’t one-size-fits-all. With multiple carrier options, Keats Insurance Agencies gives you choices.
Insurance is complex, but Keats Insurance Agencies simplifies it—no jargon, just clear guidance.
Your needs change over time. Keats Insurance Agencies offers annual reviews to keep your coverage and costs optimized

50+

Staff Members

A team committed to Excellence & Personal Service. We are dedicated to providing thoughtful guidance and personalized service to every client.

100+

Carrier Relationships

We work with 100+ carriers, giving us access to a wide range of coverage options. This allows us to compare rates and secure affordable, tailored insurance solutions our clients.

Nationwide Insurance Hall of Fame Agency - keatsagency.com

This is insurance done the Keats Insurance Agencies Insurance way.

Let us help you find insurance protection that is right for YOU.

A legacy of success just got stronger.

Keats Insurance Agencies is proud to be named a Best Practices Agency!

Big I 2026

Our company earned this elite status by ranking among the top performers in the Best Practices Study by the Independent Insurance Agents & Brokers of America (IIABA) and Reagan Consulting. This study identifies the nation’s top agencies based on growth, profitability, productivity, and financial stability. Of 36,000 independent agencies, only 2,600 were nominated, and just 282 qualified-including us! This recognition highlights our commitment to excellence and positions us as an industry leader!

Member of Trusted Choice Independent Insurance Agencies – Professional Insurance Industry Affiliation - keatsagency.com
Big I 2026
Member of Trusted Choice Independent Insurance Agencies – Professional Insurance Industry Affiliation - keatsagency.com

Keats Insurance Agencies was inducted into the Nationwide Insurance Hall of Fame in 2014.

This honor recognizes a career of industry leadership and a long-term production of personal, commercial and life insurance, year-over-year growth and commitment to helping more people protect what matters most to them throughout their lifetimes and business careers.

OUR VISION

OUR VALUES & BELIEFS

OUR MISSION

Keats Agency was inducted into the Nationwide Insurance Hall of Fame in 2014.

This honor recognizes a career of industry leadership and a long-term production of personal, commercial and life insurance, year-over-year growth and commitment to helping more people protect what matters most to them throughout their lifetimes and business careers.

OUR VISION

OUR MISSION

OUR VISION

We Represent the Nation’s Top Carriers

Keats Insurance Agencies works with many of the Nation’s top carriers. The extensive list include: Nationwide, Hartford, Liberty Mutual, Allstate, Progressive, Safeco, Travelers, Hanover, Plymouth Rock, Chubb, PURE, Private Client, Hagerty and many others.

Testimonials

Find A Location Near You


Mineola, NY

Keats Insurance Agency headquarters in Mineola, New York - keatsagency.com

485 Jericho Turnpike
Mineola, NY 11501
(800) 871-1992
service@keatsagency.com

  • Baldwin, NY

    Keats Insurance Agency office location in Baldwin, NY - keatsagency.com
    1884 Grand Ave.
    Baldwin, NY 11510
    (516) 379-0600
    service@keatsagency.com
  • Florida, NY

    Keats Insurance Agency office in Florida, New York - keatsagency.com
    103 N Main St.
    Florida, NY 10921
    (800) 871-1992
    service@keatsagency.com
  • Fort Myers, FL

    Keats Insurance Agency Florida branch in Fort Myers - keatsagency.com
    4111 Otter Bend Circle
    Fort Myers, FL 33905
    (800) 871-1992
    service@keatsagency.com
  • Keats Insurance Agency Affiliations